From Immigrant Family to the Nation’s Top Immigration Chief: An Interview with Alejandro Mayorkas

0
Image by the Harvard Institute of Politics.

Alejandro Mayorkas is the former U.S. Secretary of Homeland Security, serving under the Biden administration from 2021-2025. Prior to this role, Mayorkas worked in private law practice and as the U.S. Attorney for the Central District of California from 1998-2001 after being nominated by President Bill Clinton. From 2013-2016, Mayorkas then held the position of Deputy Secretary of Homeland Security under the Obama administration. As a 2026 Harvard Institute of Politics resident fellow, Mayorkas sat down with the HPR to discuss his career journey, immigration policy achievements, and criticisms of them.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

Harvard Political Review: Please introduce yourself, your background growing up, and how you got into your career in public service.

Alejandro Mayorkas: I was born in Havana, Cuba, as was my sister and father. My mother was born in Romania and fled World War II and could only travel safely with her parents to Cuba. My father was educated in college and graduate school in the states, but returned to his home country to start a business there when the Cuban Revolution occurred. My father and mother did not want to raise their children under a communist regime, so we left Cuba and came to the United States. We lived in Miami for a few years, and my father, who really had to start all over again, found better work in Los Angeles. I grew up most of my life in Los Angeles. I always had a desire to enter government service, because this country gave everything to my family and created opportunities we would never have had in the country of my birth, and I wanted to give back.

HPR: That’s a great reason to go into public service. Coming from an immigrant family, you probably have a unique perspective on the issue of immigration and immigration policy. How do you think your personal and family experience influence the way you think about these issues?

AM: I certainly have a deep appreciation for this country’s identity as a place of refuge for those fleeing persecution. I understand the trauma that is involved when someone leaves the country of one’s birth, where one lives not necessarily by pure choice, but by compulsion, and I understand the fragility of life and the difficulties sometimes of the journey, and I also carry with me a deep and profound patriotism. 

HPR: Following up on how you got into public service, one of the first roles you had in immigration was at the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). Can you discuss that role a little bit?

AM: My public service actually began in 1989 in the administration of George Bush, Sr. I started as a career government servant, as a federal prosecutor. I was a prosecutor trying criminal cases for about eight and a half years, and then I was promoted to the position of United States Attorney, which was a political appointment in the administration of President Clinton.

HPR: In that part of your life where you worked as a prosecutor and then got appointed by Clinton into that position, what work do you feel like you did in that capacity [that] shaped your thinking in the later part of your career? 

AM: I did not focus on immigration law and policy. Before, I was focused on law enforcement and criminal justice, and subsequently, as the deputy secretary and the secretary. My portfolio was far broader than immigration exclusively, but I developed a reverence for the men and women in law enforcement, their mission of public safety, and their courage in sacrificing their own well-being to keep others safe.

Advertisement

HPR: What is your most proud accomplishment in your role at USCIS?

AM: Let me take a step back first. I had wanted to enter the Obama administration, continuing my work in criminal justice, but I had the good fortune of meeting Secretary Janet Napolitano, the Homeland Security Secretary in the first term of President Obama’s administration. She was very intrigued by my identity as an immigrant, but also my background in law enforcement. The premier responsibility in the Department of Homeland Security is the counterterrorism mission, and so my background in law enforcement, she felt, would facilitate the advancement of that mission. At USCIS, I created the Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate to better accomplish that mission. The creation and building of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program (DACA), was something I’m deeply proud of.

HPR: Regarding counterterrorism, what challenges did you feel navigating the landscape of that specific area, especially in a post-911 era?

AM: The gravity of the challenges cannot be overstated. I don’t think that the American public appreciates the extraordinary capacity in a post-9/11 world, the maturity of the counterterrorism architecture in the federal government, and the threats that were thwarted by not just DHS, but by the FBI, by the law enforcement and intelligence community — on the federal level, but also on the state and local level, working collaboratively. The threat streams are diverse, they are grave, and I have everlasting respect for the people who dedicate themselves to that mission, to fighting it.

HPR: I was curious to hear your thoughts on public concerns that arose during the initial counterterrorism efforts in the Bush administration, especially regarding privacy rights concerns and racial profiling of certain ethnic groups in the crackdown on protecting national security.

AM: In the Department of Homeland Security, we have a statutorily created Office of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties and an Office of Privacy. It is absolutely critical that we accomplish our national security mission, our national security imperative, while respecting individuals’ constitutional rights. Racial profiling is not acceptable. It is important that we do have to make certain sacrifices, not in terms of our constitutional rights, but certain sacrifices in our daily lives, in the service of our security mission. For example, we have to go through screening at airports. You don’t know a world when there weren’t magnetometers, the metal detectors at the airport.

HPR: I want to shift back to DACA for a moment, since you mentioned that was one of the biggest immigration policies in the Obama administration. How would you describe the policy?

AM: The policy is very clear in writing that individuals who were of a certain age and were brought to this country at a certain age, met certain requirements — such as no criminal history, etc — were eligible. People who met a certain criteria, because they really knew no other country other than the United States. Those of us in positions of leadership felt it would be unjust to return them by reason of their unlawful presence in the United States to a country that was completely foreign to them. The idea was to provide them with lawful presence. They didn’t necessarily have a path to citizenship, for example, but they had a lawful presence so that they could continue in their education and continue to work and contribute to society. 

HPR: I want to hear your responses to some criticisms of DACA. Firstly, if people entered unlawfully in the first place — granted we’re talking about minors brought across the border — what incentives does it create if the system allows unlawful individuals, though minors, into the country? Secondly, from the direction of a lot of pro-immigration advocates, why not give these people a potential pathway to citizenship?

AM: With the second, Congress is the only body that can provide a path to citizenship for the DACA recipients, unless there is another path already existent in immigration law. That cannot be accomplished by executive action. Lawful presence was the Obama administration’s interpretation. Although that has been challenged in the courts: whether DACA is even lawful with the extension of a limited lawful presence, as distinguished from a path to citizenship. With respect to the first, these are minors, and so it’s quite different than an individual who enters the country essentially voluntarily, versus an individual who is brought to the country by their parents or an adult and isn’t necessarily making a knowing involuntary selection.

HPR: What about the issue of unaccompanied minors?

AM: We are a nation of immigrants, and we are a nation of laws. An individual who is brought here as an unaccompanied or arrives at the border as an unaccompanied child doesn’t necessarily have a basis to remain. They also have to have a legal basis to remain in the United States. They have to meet certain qualifications. For example, to qualify as a special immigrant juvenile — that’s a construct under immigration law. But let’s take a step back and look at the humanity of the situation and think about the desperation that a parent or parents must feel to send their child. It speaks of the desperation of humans in our world. 

HPR: During the Biden administration, there was a lot of public debate over the DHS’s decision to discontinue at one point the “Remain in Mexico” policy. What are your responses to the criticisms of that decision, particularly people who say that it also corresponded with an uptick in attempts at border crossings?

AM: One, that was a campaign promise of presidential candidate Biden at the time, and he fulfilled that promise. That was an executive decision. Secondly, on the evidence that the “Remain in Mexico” policy was a significant factor in the reduction of individuals encountered at the border, the evidence doesn’t necessarily support that.

HPR: Beyond evidence and from a principled standpoint, why shouldn’t we incentivize other countries to accept some sort of responsibility for tackling the immigration crisis?

AM: That’s a very different question, and a very apt question. We did speak to leaders in other countries that were countries of transit, and said, “No, you need to enforce your borders, and you need to develop an asylum system in your country, and you cannot serve as a simple pass through to the United States.” During the Biden years, the subject of immigration was not exclusive to the United States; it was a mass migration globally, a human phenomenon of that magnitude and of that nature, requiring a multilateral response.

HPR: What’s your response to people who are fed up with the situation of ICE raids and have been calling to abolish ICE, specifically as someone who has led in a federal immigration position at DHS?

AM: I agree with the removal of individuals who are unlawfully present in the United States and pose a public safety threat to our communities. I am for immigration enforcement, focused on that priority area and some other priority areas, such as recent border crossers, which we made a priority in the Biden administration. The tactics we have seen employed over the last 18 months raise grave concerns. The focus on enforcement is not based exclusively on certain priority areas, but is casting a wide net, even on people who have been here for many, many years and have been valuable in contributing to our communities. 

I do not agree with the notion of abolishing ICE. ICE is a very able immigration and law enforcement agency with varied missions. Homeland Security investigations is a criminal investigative arm within ICE that fights the fentanyl epidemic, the pandemic of online child sexual exploitation and abuse, and investigates and prosecutes customs violations. We need enforcement and removal operations from ICE. We do have people unlawfully present in the United States who pose a risk to our community and should be deported.

HPR: What was your reaction to the political firestorm over the GOP-led impeachment trial of you?

AM: I didn’t agree with the proceedings, as almost every legal scholar did as well. I disagreed with it, but nevertheless, I was not distracted by it. I focused on the mission, and fulfilling my responsibilities as secretary.

Advertisement